I have uploaded a review in PDF format (attached).
We are very grateful for Lightner's review. In response, we made the following changes:
Furthermore, we refer now to cooperation in more abstract terms, to emphasise that the mechanism discussed applies not only cellular biomass but also more generally to any shareable resource.
Cooperation is a persistent behavioral pattern of entities pooling and sharing resources. Its ubiquity in nature poses a conundrum: whenever two entities cooperate, one must willingly relinquish something of value to the other. Why is this apparent altruism favored in evolution? Classical treatments assume a priori a net fitness gain in a cooperative transaction which, through reciprocity or relatedness, finds its way back from recipient to donor. Our analysis makes no such assumption. It rests on the insight that evolutionary processes are typically multiplicative and noisy. Fluctuations have a net negative effect on the long-time growth rate of resources but no effect on the growth rate of their expectation value. This is a consequence of non-ergodicity. Pooling and sharing reduces the amplitude of fluctuations and, therefore, increases the long-time growth rate for cooperators. Put simply, cooperators' resources outgrow those of similar non-cooperators. This constitutes a fundamental and widely applicable mechanism for the evolution of cooperation. Furthermore, its minimal assumptions make it a candidate explanation in simple settings, where other explanations, such as emergent function and specialization, are implausible. An example of this is the transition from single cells to early multicellular life.
➤ Version 1 (2019-03-05)
Ole Peters and Alexander Adamou (2019). An evolutionary advantage of cooperation. Researchers.One, https://researchers.one/articles/an-evolutionary-advantage-of-cooperation/5f52699c36a3e45f17ae7dc8/v1.